Insights · Carbon potential
Carbon sequestration per hectare for tropical tree planting
How much carbon sequestration per hectare can a tropical tree-planting project expect? The honest first answer comes from the IPCC's default growth rates, and they vary more than most people think: from under 1 tCO2e per hectare per year on dry African shrubland to about 13 in African rainforest. This post sets out the rates we have used in real screenings, how they are converted, how wide the error bars are, and what they add up to over 40 years.
Carbon sequestration per hectare: the IPCC rates by zone
The IPCC publishes default growth rates for forests in the 2019 Refinement to its 2006 Guidelines for national greenhouse gas inventories. The table that matters for tree planting on open land is Table 4.9 in Volume 4, Chapter 4 (Forest Land): above-ground net biomass growth in natural forests, by climate domain, ecological zone and continent. For each tropical zone it gives a rate for secondary forest up to 20 years old and a rate for secondary forest older than 20 years.
These are the rates our screening engine applies. The table below shows every zone and continent combination we have used on real sites so far, converted from tonnes of dry matter to tonnes of CO2 equivalent.
| Ecological zone, continent | Up to 20 years | Over 20 years | 40-year total, gross | Where we used it |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tropical rainforest, Africa | 13.097 | 6.032 | 382.6 | Côte d’Ivoire, Cameroon |
| Tropical rainforest, Americas | 10.168 | 3.964 | 282.6 | Colombia (Llanos, by rainfall) |
| Tropical mountain system, Africa | 9.478 | 3.102 | 251.6 | Uganda, Tanzania |
| Tropical dry forest, Africa | 6.721 | 2.757 | 189.6 | West African savanna |
| Tropical rainforest, Asia | 5.859 | 4.653 | 210.2 | Borneo |
| Tropical moist deciduous forest, Africa | 4.998 | 1.551 | 131.0 | Malawi, DR Congo, Kenya |
| Subtropical dry forest, Africa | 4.136 | 3.102 | 144.8 | South Africa |
| Tropical shrublands, Africa | 0.775 | 1.551 | 46.5 | Kenya drylands |
The spread is the first thing to see. A hectare of regrowing African rainforest adds about 17 times as much above-ground carbon in its first 20 years as a hectare of African shrubland. Your ecological zone sets the ceiling of the carbon case before a single tree is chosen.
Note one quirk. Our Colombian site sits in the Llanos savanna, but with about 2,800 mm of rain a year it falls in the tropical rainforest zone of the global ecological zone map. Zones follow climate, not the vegetation you see on the ground today.
From biomass to CO2: the conversion
IPCC tables are in tonnes of dry matter (d.m.). Carbon credits are in tonnes of CO2 equivalent. The conversion has three steps.
Dry matter to carbon
Multiply by the default carbon fraction of wood, 0.47. That figure comes from the 2006 Guidelines (Table 4.3) and was not changed in the 2019 Refinement.
Carbon to CO2
Multiply by 44/12, the ratio of the molecular weight of CO2 to that of carbon, about 3.667. Together the two steps mean one tonne of dry biomass is about 1.72 tCO2.
Add the roots
Table 4.9 is above ground only. Below-ground biomass is added with a root-to-shoot ratio (R) from Table 4.4. In the tropics R ranges from about 0.2 (rainforest in the Americas and Asia) to 0.825 (young African rainforest), so roots can add a fifth or more than three-quarters to the above-ground figure.
A worked example: Table 4.9 gives 7.6 t d.m. per hectare per year for African rainforest up to 20 years old. 7.6 × 0.47 × 44/12 = 13.097 tCO2e above ground, the figure in the table above.
Why young and older stands differ
In seven of the eight zones in our table, the rate up to 20 years is higher than the rate after. That is what forest ecology predicts. A young stand on open land has light, space and little competition; it closes its canopy and adds wood fast. As it ages, trees compete, some die, and net growth slows. The table measures net growth, so mortality is already subtracted.
African tropical shrublands are the odd one out: 0.775 tCO2e per hectare per year for young stands, 1.551 for older ones. The source table gives the young rate as a range (0.2–0.7 t d.m.) rather than a single value, and the older figure (0.9 t d.m.) is identical to the primary-forest figure. Our engine uses the midpoint of the range. A plausible reading is that dry-land trees establish slowly and only build biomass once roots reach water, but the table does not explain the pattern, and the IPCC default uncertainty for these rows is ±90%. Treat both numbers as rough. Our Kenyan dryland screening applied the young-stand rate of 0.775 for all 40 years and then added roots (× 1.4): about 43 tCO2e per hectare over 40 years, gross.
- Fastest young rate we used13.1 tCO2e/ha/yr
- Slowest young rate we used0.8 tCO2e/ha/yr
- SourceIPCC 2019, Table 4.9
How wide the error bars are
Every Tier 1 rate comes with an uncertainty. Some rows give a standard deviation from the underlying studies; others carry the IPCC default of ±90%. Both are wide.
- African rainforest, up to 20 years: 7.6 ± 5.9 t d.m. That puts one standard deviation at 2.93–23.27 tCO2e per hectare per year above ground, a factor of eight between the ends.
- Rainforest in the Americas, up to 20 years: 5.9 ± 2.5 t d.m., or 5.859–14.476 tCO2e.
- African shrublands, up to 20 years: ±90% default, or 0.078–1.473 tCO2e.
- African mountain systems, up to 20 years: 5.5 t d.m. with a standard deviation of 6.8, larger than the mean itself.
This is why our studies report three cases, conservative, average and optimistic, rather than one number. On the Uganda mountain site the 40-year gross range ran from about 5,200 to 457,200 tCO2e for the same 664 hectares. That is not a modelling failure. It is an honest picture of how little a global default knows about one site.
What it means per hectare over 40 years
Multiply out the table and you get a first idea of gross removals per hectare over a 40-year crediting horizon. All figures below are above-ground, gross, average-case Tier 1 values:
- African rainforest: 20 × 13.097 + 20 × 6.032 = about 383 tCO2e per hectare, or 9.6 a year on average.
- African moist deciduous forest (miombo country): about 131 tCO2e per hectare, or 3.3 a year.
- African tropical shrublands: about 47 tCO2e per hectare, or 1.2 a year.
Then roots. Our Malawi screening sits in the moist deciduous zone, where Table 4.4 gives R = 0.232 for African natural forest. 131.0 × 1.232 is about 161 tCO2e per hectare. Across 105,200 eligible hectares that is about 17.0 million tCO2e gross in the average case, which is the figure in the study.
Gross is not what a project sells. The screening then deducts uncertainty (10%, the minimum VM0047 v1.1 sets for ex-ante estimates), a non-permanence buffer (15%, the median of 198 registered ARR projects in our registry data) and leakage. In our anonymised sample study, a dryland site in East Africa, 69,779 tCO2e gross became a net screening estimate of −2,976 tCO2e after deductions, mainly because leakage from displaced grazing took 79% of gross. See gross vs net carbon credits and leakage in ARR projects for how each line works.
Tier 1 vs Tier 2 and Tier 3
The IPCC uses tiers to describe how specific the data is. Tier 1 is the global default by zone and continent, the numbers in this post. Tier 2 uses country- or region-specific factors, such as national growth curves for the species you plant. Tier 3 uses measured data and models for the site itself: inventory plots, species-specific allometric equations and growth-and-yield models.
Table 4.9 describes natural regrowth. Plantations are in Table 4.10, which lists genus-level rates and often much higher ones; a fast-growing plantation and a native mixed planting in the same zone can differ several-fold. That is one reason species choice matters, covered in best trees for carbon capture in the tropics.
Under VM0047, credits are not issued on any IPCC default. The area-based approach estimates biomass from field plots and allometric equations, then compares the project with matched control plots through a dynamic performance benchmark. Tier 1 is a screening tool: it tells you whether the carbon case is in the right range before you pay for plots and models. That is the role it plays in our carbon feasibility study and on the reforestation feasibility page.
Frequently asked questions
Using IPCC 2019 Tier 1 defaults for regrowing tropical forest, above-ground growth ranges from about 0.8 tCO2e per hectare per year in African tropical shrublands to about 13 tCO2e in African rainforest during the first 20 years. Over 40 years that is roughly 47 to 383 tCO2e per hectare above ground, before roots are added and before any deductions. Real sites can sit well outside these defaults.
Multiply tonnes of dry biomass by the IPCC default carbon fraction of 0.47 to get tonnes of carbon, then by 44/12 (about 3.667) to get tonnes of CO2. One tonne of dry biomass is therefore about 1.72 tCO2. Below-ground biomass is added with a root-to-shoot ratio from IPCC Table 4.4, which ranges from about 0.2 to over 0.8 in the tropics.
In most tropical zones, Table 4.9 gives a higher rate for secondary forest up to 20 years old than for older forest. Young stands are closing their canopy and putting on wood fast; older stands slow down as mortality and competition catch up with growth. African tropical shrublands are the exception in the table, where the older rate is higher.
No. Tier 1 defaults are fine for a screening, because they show whether a site is in the right order of magnitude. Credits under VM0047 are issued on measured growth, using plot data and allometric equations, compared against a dynamic performance benchmark. A project design needs Tier 2 or Tier 3 data: local growth curves, species-specific equations and field plots.
Sources
- IPCC (2019) 2019 Refinement to the 2006 IPCC Guidelines, Volume 4 (AFOLU), Chapter 4 Forest Land, Tables 4.4, 4.9 and 4.10
- IPCC (2019) Chapter 4 Forest Land (PDF)
- Verra: VM0047 Afforestation, Reforestation and Revegetation, v1.1
- Hansen et al. (2013), Global Forest Change dataset, download and layer definitions