Insights · Land eligibility

The forest definition for carbon credits, and the 10-year rule

For tree-planting carbon credits, the forest definition decides which land is in and which is out. The rules look back in time too: what the land was in the ten years before your project starts. This post explains both, in the wording the documents actually use, and how a satellite screening checks them.

Feasibility.Earth team, Green Earth Group · Updated

Why the forest definition decides carbon credit eligibility

Tree-planting projects (afforestation, reforestation and revegetation, or ARR) are built to create new tree cover where there is none. Verra's methodology VM0047 does allow some projects that add carbon to existing forest, but planting on land without forest is the core case, and it is the case our screenings study. So the first question about any hectare is simple: is it forest today, and was it recently?

The answer depends on a definition with three numbers: a minimum area, a minimum canopy cover and a minimum tree height. Change one number and the same hectare can flip from forest to non-forest.

The FAO forest definition

The UN Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) uses one definition for its Global Forest Resources Assessment. Forest is land spanning more than 0.5 hectares with trees higher than 5 metres and canopy cover of more than 10%, or trees able to reach those thresholds in place. Land that is predominantly under agricultural or urban use is not forest.

The explanatory notes matter as much as the numbers:

  • Tree stands in agricultural production systems are excluded: fruit tree plantations, oil palm plantations, olive orchards and agroforestry with crops grown under tree cover.
  • Rubber-wood and cork oak plantations are included, and so are bamboo and palms where land use, height and canopy criteria are met.
  • Young stands expected to reach the thresholds, and areas cleared but expected to regenerate, still count as forest.

Below the forest line, FAO has a second class, other wooded land: 5–10% canopy of trees over 5 metres, or a combined cover of shrubs, bushes and trees above 10%. Much of the dry savanna where ARR projects are proposed falls here, or below it.

National thresholds: 0.05–1 ha, 10–30% canopy, 2–5 m

Carbon projects rarely use the FAO definition alone. Under the Kyoto Protocol (UNFCCC decision 16/CMP.1), forest is a minimum area of 0.05–1.0 hectare with tree crown cover of more than 10–30% and trees able to reach 2–5 metres at maturity. Each country selected a single value for each parameter, and these national choices were used for tree-planting projects under the Clean Development Mechanism. The VCS Standard, for its forest-protection category, refers to the same two families: definitions based on UNFCCC host-country thresholds, or FAO definitions.

Forest definitions compared
FAO (FRA)Kyoto / CDM national choice
Minimum areaMore than 0.5 haOne value between 0.05 and 1 ha
Minimum canopy coverMore than 10%One value between 10% and 30%
Minimum tree height5 m (or able to reach it)One value between 2 and 5 m (at maturity)
Land use testExcludes agricultural and urban landSet by the country

The canopy value moves the most land. A woodland with 20% crown cover is forest in a country that chose 10%, and non-forest in a country that chose 30%. Check your host country's values with its designated national authority before you design anything.

The 10-year rule: what Verra's documents say

People often speak of “the 10-year rule” as if it were one sentence. In the current documents it is several look-back tests that share a purpose: nobody should earn credits for clearing land and then replanting it.

  1. Managed forest (VM0047, area-based). The methodology does not apply where the land met the definition of managed forest, meaning forest actively managed for wood products, at any point in the ten years immediately before the project start date. Clearing existing woody biomass by harvesting timber, or in a way that degrades native ecosystems, is also excluded.
  2. Existing forest (VM0047 scope). Projects that enhance carbon in existing forest are only eligible where that forest has not been managed for wood products in the past ten years.
  3. Removed trees (VM0047, census-based). The methodology does not apply where woody biomass serving a similar purpose to the new planting was removed within the last ten years.
  4. Degraded ecosystems (VCS Standard v4.7). Activities that convert an ecosystem may only take place in degraded ecosystems. Where the ecosystem was degraded within ten years of the start date, the project must show the degradation was not caused by the project activity, for example that it followed a flood or hurricane. No such evidence is needed if the degradation happened at least ten years earlier.

A screening cannot read intent, but it can see the pattern these rules target: tree cover that was there and disappeared shortly before a project. That is why recent forest loss inside the boundary is treated as a red flag and excluded.

  • Look-back period10 years before start
  • TestsManaged forest, removals, degradation
  • Screened withHansen GFC loss year

How a screening checks forest history, and where the data falls short

Our screening uses the Hansen Global Forest Change dataset, a 30-metre global map. Two layers do the work. Tree cover in 2000 gives the canopy closure of all vegetation taller than 5 metres. Loss year records stand-replacing disturbance, a change from forest to non-forest, for each year since 2001. The current release runs to 2024.

The screening classes each pixel as forest or not in 2000 using a canopy threshold, removes pixels with loss in the last ten years, and then removes built-up land, water and wetland, slopes over 30° and recently converted native vegetation. What remains is the eligible area. The method is described on the methodology page and in satellite data for carbon project assessment.

The data has real limits, and a good report names them:

  • Tree cover is not land use. Hansen counts any vegetation over 5 metres. Rubber, oil palm, orchards and shade-grown cocoa or coffee can all read as tree cover, even where FAO would call the land agricultural.
  • 2000 is a snapshot. Trees that grew after 2000 are not in the 2000 layer. A site with young regrowth can look less forested than it is today.
  • Global thresholds are not national ones. The canopy line a screening uses may differ from the value your country chose.
  • Small patches blur. A 30-metre pixel is 0.09 hectare. Definitions with a 0.05-hectare minimum operate below the resolution of the map.

What real sites show

Across 17 distinct sites we have screened, the forest-cover history decided more than any other layer. The median site was 40.7% eligible. Six of the 17 sites were under 11% eligible, and every one of them had at least 66% of its area classed as forest in 2000. Every site with 9% or less classed as forest in 2000 was at least 90% eligible.

  • Our anonymised sample study, on dry bushland in East Africa: 0 hectares classed as forest in 2000, and 1,608 of 1,698 hectares (94.7%) eligible. The only exclusion was built-up land, about 90 hectares of homesteads and roads, not forest.
  • A cocoa and forest landscape in Côte d'Ivoire: 91% classed as forest in 2000, 7.6% eligible. Some of that “forest” may be shaded cocoa, which is exactly where satellite data and the FAO definition disagree and field evidence is needed.
  • A coffee and tea landscape in Kenya: 39% classed as forest in 2000, 61.4% eligible.

All 17 sites are compared in ARR land eligibility: what 17 desktop screenings show. The difference between afforestation and reforestation, which matters much less than this test, is covered in afforestation vs reforestation.

What to do next

Start with your country's forest thresholds, then look at your boundary on the Global Forest Change map. If large parts show tree cover in 2000 or loss in the last decade, expect a smaller eligible area. For one defensible figure, the Eligibility Check runs the full exclusion cascade pixel by pixel. It is the first step of a carbon feasibility study.

Frequently asked questions

There is no single global answer. FAO defines forest as land over 0.5 hectares with trees taller than 5 metres and more than 10% canopy cover, excluding farmland and towns. Under the Kyoto Protocol rules, each country chose its own thresholds within set ranges: 0.05 to 1 hectare, 10 to 30% crown cover and 2 to 5 metres tree height. Carbon standards refer to these definitions.

Sources

Find out how much of your land counts as forest

The Eligibility Check maps forest in 2000, recent loss, built-up land, water and steep slopes inside your boundary, and gives one eligible-area figure. $500, 2–3 business days.