Insights · Land eligibility

Afforestation vs reforestation: the difference, and what it means for carbon credits

Afforestation and reforestation both mean planting trees where there is no forest now. The difference is history: whether the land was ever forest. For carbon credits under VM0047 the label matters much less than one question underneath it: was this land forest, or cleared, in the years before your project starts?

Feasibility.Earth team, Green Earth Group · Updated

The definitions

Afforestation is establishing forest on land that has not been forest for a long time. Reforestation is re-establishing forest on land that was forest and was converted to another use, such as cropland or pasture. The everyday difference is simply: was there forest here before?

The carbon market inherited precise versions of these words from the Kyoto Protocol. Under the Clean Development Mechanism (UNFCCC decision 16/CMP.1), afforestation meant converting land that had not been forest for at least 50 years, and reforestation meant converting land that was not forest on 31 December 1989. Those dates were there to stop countries claiming credit for replanting forest they had just cut down.

Afforestation and reforestation side by side
AfforestationReforestation
Land historyNot forest for a long time, or neverWas forest, then converted
Typical land todayNatural grassland, savanna, long-term croplandDegraded pasture, abandoned farmland, cleared forest land
CDM test (historic)Non-forest for at least 50 yearsNon-forest on 31 December 1989
Under VM0047Part of ARRPart of ARR
Main ecological questionIs a forest right for this ecosystem?What stops the forest coming back by itself?

A third word completes the set. Revegetation means establishing woody vegetation that does not reach the forest definition: shrubs, or trees too sparse or too short to count as forest. It matters on drylands, where a closed forest is neither possible nor desirable.

One activity: afforestation, reforestation and revegetation (ARR)

Verra's current methodology for tree planting, VM0047, puts all three under one activity: afforestation, reforestation and revegetation, or ARR. The quantification is the same whichever word describes your site. Growth, the baseline, uncertainty, leakage and the non-permanence buffer are all handled the same way.

So if you are asking “is my project afforestation or reforestation?” because you think one earns more credits, it does not. The credits depend on how much carbon the trees add compared with what would have happened anyway, after the deductions explained in gross vs net carbon credits.

  • MethodologyVM0047 (ARR)
  • CoversAfforestation, reforestation, revegetation
  • IncludesAgroforestry and woodlots

The test that does matter: forest now, and clearing before

What decides whether land can host an ARR project is its recent past, not its label. In VM0047 version 1.1 the main tests are these:

  1. The core case is non-forest land. Projects establish, increase or restore vegetation cover in areas without forest. (Version 1.1 also lets area-based projects add carbon to existing forest that has not been managed for wood products in the past ten years; our screenings cover the non-forest planting case.) What counts as forest follows a definition with thresholds for area, tree height and canopy cover. Read the forest definition and the 10-year rule.
  2. A ten-year look-back. The area-based approach excludes land that met the definition of managed forest at any point in the ten years before the project start, and clearing that involves timber harvest or degrades native ecosystems. Where the ecosystem was degraded within those ten years, the VCS Standard asks for evidence that the project did not cause it. The point is that nobody is rewarded for clearing in order to replant.

None of these conditions asks whether your project is afforestation or reforestation. A site of abandoned farmland that was forest 40 years ago (reforestation) and a natural grassland that never was (afforestation) can both pass. A plantation harvested five years ago fails, whatever you call it.

The grassland case raises a separate, ecological question: planting trees in a natural grassland or savanna can harm the ecosystem that is there. A good feasibility study flags native non-forest ecosystems rather than treating every treeless hectare as an opportunity.

What real sites show

We have screened 17 distinct sites in Africa, Latin America and Asia. The share of land that passed the eligibility tests ranged from over 99% to under 1%. The deciding factor was nearly always the same: how much of the site was already forest in 2000 and how much forest was lost since.

  • On open savanna in West Africa, dry bushland in Kenya and pasture in Colombia's Llanos, where under 10% of the land was classed as forest, more than 90% of the area was eligible.
  • On rainforest sites in Cameroon and Borneo, where 98–99.5% of the land was already forest, 2% or less was eligible. Those landscapes call for protecting standing forest, which is not ARR, or for forest enhancement, which our screenings do not cover.

The full numbers are in ARR land eligibility: what 17 desktop screenings show.

How to check your own land

You can do a first check yourself: open the Global Forest Change map (Hansen et al.) and look at tree cover in 2000 and loss year by year inside your boundary. Large areas of tree cover, or loss in the last ten years, are warning signs.

A screening does the same pixel by pixel, adds built-up land, water and wetland, steep slopes and conversion of native vegetation, and gives one eligible-area figure that the rest of the study uses. That is what our Eligibility Check delivers for $500.

Frequently asked questions

Afforestation is planting trees on land that has not been forest for a long time, or ever. Reforestation is planting trees on land that was forest and was cleared. Under the old UN Clean Development Mechanism the line was drawn by date: land had to be non-forest for 50 years to count as afforestation, and non-forest on 31 December 1989 to count as reforestation.

Sources

Is your land eligible for an ARR project?

The Eligibility Check maps forest history, built-up land, water and slopes inside your boundary and gives one eligible-area figure. $500, 2–3 business days.