Guide · Project development

Carbon project development: the path from idea to issued credits

Developing a tree-planting carbon project takes years and several independent parties. This guide sets out the stages in order, who does what, what each stage costs you in time and risk, and why the feasibility study comes first.

Feasibility.Earth team, Green Earth Group · Updated

  1. 01Pre-feasibility: eligibility
  2. 02Feasibility study
  3. 03Land, rights and consent
  4. 04Field data and PDD
  5. 05Validation and registration
  6. 06Implementation
  7. 07Monitoring and issuance
  8. 08Sales and reporting
Highlighted: the stages Feasibility.Earth covers. The rest is project development.

The stages of a carbon project

The order below is for a tree-planting (ARR) project under the Verra VCS Program and the methodology VM0047. Other standards use different names but a similar sequence.

  1. Idea and pre-feasibility

    Is the activity eligible, and is enough land eligible? An eligibility check answers this from satellite data in days.

  2. Feasibility study

    Species, carbon removals, the gross-to-net deductions, risks and next steps. The go or no-go point for spending real money. See the feasibility study guide.

  3. Land, rights and consent

    Secure the land and carbon rights, agree benefit sharing, and obtain free, prior and informed consent from the communities involved. Check host-country rules on carbon projects.

  4. Field data and project design

    Field inventories, a monitoring plan and the Project Design Document (PDD), which applies the methodology to your site.

  5. Validation and registration

    An accredited validation and verification body (VVB) audits the PDD against the standard. The project is then registered and listed on the registry.

  6. Implementation

    Nurseries, planting, protection and replanting where trees die. This is where most of the money goes.

  7. Monitoring, verification and issuance

    Each monitoring period the project measures its removals, a VVB verifies them, and the registry issues credits, minus the buffer contribution.

  8. Sales and reporting

    Credits are sold, forward or after issuance, and the project keeps reporting for its whole crediting period.

Who does what

Parties in a carbon project
RoleWhen
Landowner or communityHolds the land; agrees to the project and the benefit sharingThroughout
Project developerRuns feasibility, design, registration, implementation and monitoringThroughout
Validation and verification body (VVB)Independent audit of the design and of each monitoring reportValidation; each verification
Standard and registrySets the rules, registers the project, issues and tracks creditsRegistration; issuance
Buyer or investorFunds the project or buys the creditsBefore or after issuance

Cost and time

Costs vary too much by country, size and standard for an honest single number. The main cost items are the feasibility work, field inventories, writing the PDD, validation and verification fees, registry fees, and, by far the largest for tree planting, establishing and maintaining the trees. Ask any provider to quote each item separately; what to compare when pricing a feasibility study lists the questions to ask.

On time: tree-planting projects are slow to pay back. Credits come only after removals have happened and been verified, and young trees remove little in their first years. Plan your finance around the first verification, not the planting date. The Verra deadlines for each stage are in the ARR project timeline, and the published fees and per-hectare planting costs in what it costs to develop an ARR project.

Why the feasibility study comes first

Each stage costs more than the one before it, and the most common reasons projects fail can be seen at the start: land that does not qualify, growth too slow for the climate, leakage that eats the net, or an area too small for the fixed costs. Finding that out for $500 to $7,500 is cheaper than finding it during validation. More on this in why carbon projects fail feasibility.

Where Feasibility.Earth fits

Feasibility.Earth covers the first two stages for tree-planting projects under VM0047: the $500 Eligibility Check and the $7,500 Full Feasibility Study. Both are desktop screenings; neither is a validation or a credit claim.

For projects that pass a full study, Green Earth Group offers project development support: PDD, certification and registration, implementation, monitoring and credit sales. For some qualifying projects it considers co-investment. That is decided case by case after the study, never before. See how this compares with a consultancy.

Frequently asked questions

Start by testing whether the land and the activity can produce credits at all: a pre-feasibility or eligibility screen, then a feasibility study. Only then secure land and carbon rights, consult the communities involved, and write the Project Design Document for validation. Starting with design or marketing before feasibility is the most common expensive mistake.

Start at the beginning

Test the land before you spend on design. Eligibility Check $500, Full Feasibility Study $7,500.